2010 Soter Pinot Noir Mineral Springs Vineyard

Market price

Buying options

Tasting notes

Tasting notes
Score 93/100 · Drink 2012-2024, David Schildknecht, Wine Advocate, Aug 2012

Rose petal and geranium fascinatingly mingle with scents of cherry and almond in the nose of Soter’s 2010 Pinot Noir Mineral Springs Ranch; then inform a silken-textured, infectiously-juicy palate, rich in ripe cherry and piquant nut oils yet buoyant and positively billowing in its expression of inner-mouth florality, leading to a long, mouthwateringly savory, disarmingly persistent and next sip-inducing finish in which floral and spice accents alluringly keep pace with the generous flow of fruit. Look for at least a dozen years of delight from this polished beauty, which will almost certainly gain in complex allure and fascination. Tony Soter has been making wine in his native state for long enough now that this iconic figure of California wine history can be said to have achieved a similar status in Oregon. His 30 acres of Pinot Noir vines and two of Chardonnay planted on the self-contained, east-west oriented and unusually fast-draining as well as sun- and wind-exposed ridge that is Mineral Springs vineyard, can be said to have reached maturity, a sign of which is the ripping-out of drip lines at the time of my visit that were helpful in establishing the vineyard but whose use Soter is convinced are unnecessary for the future. (Even in torrid July 2009 – which happens to have coincided with my own previous and memorable visit – he reports that they were scarcely utilized.) “Grass is the brake and the throttle for vines,” quips Soter by way of explaining his green rows and organic methods, and adds that while he continues to prepare small amounts of “green manure,” he has thus far not added any such nitrogen supplements to Mineral Springs. “This site tends toward early and complete lignification of stems,” notes winemaker and long-time Soter right-hand James Cahill, which explains his successful employment in recent years of 25% or more whole clusters – and not only in ripe vintages like 2009 – a technique Soter and Cahill are convinced conduces to enhanced fragrance and finesse. I’m already confident in making certain points about vine selection that I’ll nonetheless defer until the introduction to next year’s Oregon report; but that said, let me at least note that Soter’s employment of old heirloom selections he brought with him from California (and that long informed special bottlings under his Etude label) has without question been instrumental in the delicious distinctiveness of his Mineral Ridge bottlings. Besides conducing to complexity, notes Soter, “these vines feature loose, small-, often seedless-berried, and consequently disease-resistant clusters, and they self-regulate to low tonnage, requiring only a finessed thinning for uniformity; whereas with clones we end up throwing a lot of their fruit on the ground.” As a bonus, Soter found that these tiny berries more easily retain elasticity and hence phenolic quality in the Willamette Valley than they did in more heat-prone Northern California. (Heirloom selections cover 15 of the 22 acres Soter typically utilized for still wine, the rest featuring a mix of traditional Pommard selections and Wadenswil – a pair he in fact favors for his sparkling wine-destined parcels – and selected Dijon clones.) Revealing something of his stylistic vision for Pinot, Soter suggests that “the most successful wines are nowadays being measured by their phenolic concentration and their sheer ripeness; but we’re giving something up and on the wrong track to the extent we do this. I want wines that have a place to go – ones whose precious incipient aromatics turn into bottle bouquet and that have more aging potential.” The wines I tasted in June deliciously illustrated where Soter’s Pinots head over time in bottle. Methode Champenoise wine at Soter Vineyards might have begun as a way to employ young vines and to placate a predilection for pink bubbles by the estate’s and proprietor’s leading lady, but to say that the results proved serendipitously synergistic would be an understatement. Today, Soter struggles to keep up with demand, and by the time he finished planting Mineral Springs (having relied early-on in large part on the northerly Beacon Hill Vineyard that was formerly part of his estate) his notion of the optimum vine selections of Pinot and proportion of Chardonnay for sparkling wine (including an envisioned blanc de blancs) had been duly considered. Soter adds still Pinot from barrel to his pink bubbly, “but it soon became clear,” he explains, “that the grit (i.e. of tannin) not the color is your limiting factor, and that demands a certain measure of compensatory Chardonnay.” Nowadays, the modest number of barrels (or sometimes steel drums) of Pinot required for coloring represents vines and mini-lots grown and vinified expressly for that purpose, which explains why a relatively hefty dosage can be added – thus enhancing vinosity without adding excessive “grit” – but also why the percentage of Chardonnay in the cuvee will drop markedly from the 2007 vintage on. The finishing, lightly-sweetening dosage, too, involves as he puts it “reaching into the cellar for some fresh Chardonnay or Pinot, because we’ve found that this is much more satisfying than dosing the sparking wine with itself. We pick relatively late and at relatively low yields and high brix for a commercial sparkling wine producer,” he notes, “because we want to capture some real flavor,” but emphasizes that careful attention must be paid to selecting parcels and lots whose sugar, acids and phenolics will eventually enhance and not burden the finished sparklers. “The safe zone” – by which Soter alludes to the minimum ripeness needed to achieve interesting flavors and the maximum allowable brix to accommodate unproblematic secondary fermentation – “still leaves some room for risk-taking.” Tel. (503) 662-5600

Critic scores

Critic scores
93
93/100

Average Score

93
93/100

Josh Raynolds

93
93/100

David Schildknecht, Wine Advocate

More reviews and scores

93 points
Josh Raynolds
Score 93/100 · Josh Raynolds, Jul 2012

Bright ruby-red. Heady aromas of candied red fruits, incense and cola, with suave floral nuances building in the glass. Offers intense raspberry and cherry flavors and bright blood orange and spicecake qualities, along with a touch of anise. Fine-grained tannins give shape and grip to the long, nervy, focused finish. This wine should age well on its balance.

About the producer

Soter Vineyards
View Producer

Product details

Country / Region
Colour

Red

Taste

Dry

Why F+R?
Store
Store your collection in our bonded warehouse, only paying tax and duty if or when you arrange delivery.
Deliver
We sell wines and spirits to customers and clients in over 60 countries and can organise delivery to almost anywhere on the planet.
Sell
With effortless listing, promotion to our extensive network and valuation advice, there's no easier way to sell wine and spirits in your collection
Get the best F+R delivered in your inbox
Subscribe to our emails
Ⓒ 1994-2026 Fine+Rare Wines Ltd