1991 La Tache

The 1991 La Tâche Grand Cru is a remarkable wine. With a stunning nose like before, this has really opened in recent years, poised with dark berry fruit, Earl Grey and just a hint of licorice. There are many scents to lose yourself in (and it totally bosses the 1991 Chambertin from Rousseau that it is paired with). The palate is threaded through with a killer line of acidity, extraordinarily pure with tannins that melted only after a quarter-century. Lightly spiced on the finish, this is La Tâche firing on all cylinders. Tasted at the La Paulée in Beaune.

The 1991 La Tâche Grand Cru is a vintage tasted four or five times and I always prefer it to the 1990. Aubert de Villaine once remarked that it was the first vintage that he felt was fully his. I have encountered ex-domaine bottles that have been ferociously backward and require several hours of decanting. This bottle is not ex-domaine but as good as you will find. Beguiling complexity with intense mineralité on the nose, remarkable precision with that moorland scents I have noticed before. Wow. The palate is exquisitely balanced with an intensity that can knock you sideways. Crystalline in purity, the structure on the finish threatens to be too much, but I think time has mollified those tannins. Extraordinarily good but my word, you need patience. Tasted at a private dinner in Hong Kong.

Tasted at the La Tâche vertical at The Square. I tasted the La Tâche 1991 twice within 24 hours: the first ex-domaine and the second purchased from auction in Switzerland, both with Aubert de Villaine present. The former was the best, right? Wrong. It was actually the second that clearly delivered, the ex-domaine example so brutally backward that it was more impressive than a wine to love. That was not the case with the second. The nose was unapologetically ethereal with mineral-laden black fruit with hints of cold wet limestone and peaty moorland on a gloomy winter's day. The precision is quite astonishing. The palate is perfectly balanced as it glides effortlessly across the mouth, intense rather than powerful, a gentle crescendo that fans out gracefully on the finish. I have always had faith in the 1991 La Tâche and now it is coming out of the shadow of the 1990 and proving once and for all, which wine is the greater.