2004 Chambertin
Market price
Buying options
Tasting notes
Moderately saturated medium red; less bright than the '05. Wild, musky aromas of plum, pepper, clove, leather and underbrush. Then surprisingly soft, even silky, in the mouth, perhaps due to the relatively high pH, but with a streak of acidity and an herbal element running through the wine. Not especially green but a wine of modest thickness and depth. Finishes with fairly fine, dusty tannins and good length, plus a touch of sourness. Trapet described this vintage as "terribly Burgundian," comparing it to 2001 in terms of the shape of the growing season. There was a lot of oidium, as in 1998, and the + veraison was late. Trapet thinned the fruit during a humid beginning to August but then favorable anti-cyclone conditions settled in from late August through the harvest. Incidentally, Trapet bottled the '04 Chambertin with magnum corks and believes that the bottles are aging very slowly as a result. In fact, he had to find a second bottle for our tasting because the first cork was too tight to extract. (13% alcohol; 3.7 pH; 3.6 g/l acidity)
Critic scores
Average Score
Jancis Robinson MW
Stephen Tanzer, Vinous
More reviews and scores
Mid ruby. Very good complexity and integration even if not especially intense, Something quite raw and citric about it. Chewy and pretty hard work. All as a promise rather than a reality. Is it really such an attribute to be so charmless? I suspect not. Though the finish is good. (JR)
Full red. Highly nuanced, perfumed nose hints at red fruits, spices, minerals and flowers. Like liquid silk in the mouth, saturating the entire palate but retaining an almost magically light touch; this is sweet and rich yet dry in the fashion of the best Burgundies. Dense, supple and very long on the aftertaste. Among the world's pinots, only Burgundy can have texture like this.
Good medium red. Complex nose melds crushed strawberry, cherry, smoked meat, coffee, truffle and minerals. Silky and suave, but with very good mineral lift to its red fruit flavors. Compared to the Chapelle this is more primary and precise, and more vertical in shape. Quite aromatic in the mouth, and firm and minerally on the finish, which features a fine dusting of tannins.