1995 Domaine Joseph Roty Charmes-Chambertin Tres Vieilles Vignes Grand Cru
Market price
Buying options
Tasting notes
Deep, full red; remarkably dark for its age. Knockout soil-driven nose combines red and black fruits, flowers, spices, minerals, licorice and crushed stone, plus a whiff of cherry liqueur; this one displays all of this site's key food groups! A compellingly sappy, concentrated wine with terrific breadth and sweetness but also strong framing acidity to its energetic flavors of dark berries, bitter chocolate, violet, spices and salty minerality; considerably deeper than either the '96 or '98. This densely packed, seamless wine delivers an exhilarating combination of verve and sucrosité and finishes with splendid vivacity for the vintage. In fact, this particularly bottle struck me as very young, still with a lot in reserve. A second bottle tasted chez moi in January was dark red with ruby tones. It was a bit less expressive on the nose, conveying black fruits and menthol, then sappy but not particularly fleshy in the middle palate, more dominated today by its spine of acidity and tannins. While it struck me as a bit less deep than the first bottle, it nonetheless showed terrific density and thrust and came across as equally youthful. In fact, my notes say that it could go on for another 20+ years. When I first tasted this wine in bottle with Joseph Roty in 1997, he told me that the fruit was picked with potential alcohol close to 14%. And yet the pH here is the lowest of all of the wines in my vertical tasting. (ST)
Critic scores
Stephen Tanzer, Vinous
Allen Meadows, Burghound
More reviews and scores
A highly expressive nose of mature fruit that is now displaying moderate secondary nuances, spice, earth and game is trimmed in just enough wood to notice. There is outstanding richness to the big-bodied flavors that are blessed with plenty of dense old vine extract that completely coats the mouth and buffers the round, ripe tannins such that they seem almost invisible on the extended and notably sweet finish. This is a very impressive effort and while it lacks some of the detail the finest examples of this legendary wine typically display, there is so much extract that the velvety character is more than a substitute. As such, this should age for a very long time. Consistent notes.
Similar deep ruby-red. Pure perfume on the nose: cassis, kirsch, violet, licorice, tobacco, game. Like a rare liqueur whose formula is locked up in the heads of two monks. Great volume and sweetness in the mouth; fruit saturates the entire palate and anything else it can reach. Really extraordinarily concentrated. These grapes were picked with near-14% potential alcohol; the yield, according to Roty, was about 28 hectoliters per hectare, not particularly low for these ancient vines planted in 1881. Fabulous brooding fruit on the finish, along with suave, superripe tannins. Another dimension of concentration and texture.