Critic Scores

Comparison Chart

Compare the key critic scores awarded to wines in the 2019 Bordeaux En Primeur campaign with our easy to use comparison chart.

Wine Critic Key

AG = Antonio Galloni, Vinous | JA = Jane Anson, Decanter | JD =  Jeb Dunnuck, Jeb Dunnuck | JL = Jeff Leve, The Wine Cellar Insider | JS = James Suckling, JamesSuckling.com | LPB = Lisa Perrotti-Brown, The Wine Advocate | NM = Neal Martin, Vinous

WINE NAMEAVG SCOREAGJAJDJLJSLPBNM

Margaux

98.5

98-100

98

97-100

99

99-100

97-100

96-98

Lafite Rothschild

98.2

96-98

98

98-100

98-100

99-100

97-99

96-98

l'Eglise Clinet

98.2

97-99

99

96-98

98-100

97-99

Figeac

98.1

97-99

97

97-99

98-99

98-100

97-99

La Mission Haut Brion

98.1

95-97

96

98-100

99-100

98-100

98-100

Mouton Rothschild

98.1

95-97

98

97-99

98-100

99-100

98-100

96-98

Haut Brion

97.9

96-98

97

98-100

99-100

97-99+

96-98

Ducru Beaucaillou

97.9

94-96

98

97-100

98-100

99-100

97-100

96-98

Pichon Lalande

97.8

95-97

98

98-100

96-97

97-99

98-100

Trotanoy

97.8

95-97

98

97-99

98-99

97-99

97-99

Pichon Baron

97.7

96-98

97

99

97-98

97-100

96-98

Vieux Chateau Certan

97.7

95-97

97

98-100

98-99

97-100

96-98

La Conseillante

97.6

96-98

97

98-100

97-98

96-98

97-99

Haut Brion Blanc

97.5

97

97

98

100

96-98+

96

Cos d'Estournel

97.5

95-97

98

97-99

96-98

98-99

97-99

96-98

Doisy Daene Cuvee l'Extravagant

97.5

98

96-98

Leoville Lascases

97.4

94-96

98

97-99

98-99

97-99+

96-98

Angelus

97.4

95-97

97

97-99

98-99

97-99

96-98

Pavie

97.3

95-97

96

97-99

96-98

98-99

97-100

96-98

Pontet Canet

97.3

95-97

96

98-99

98-100

Haut Bailly

97.2

95-97

97

96-98

96-98

98-99

97-99

96-98

La Mission Haut Brion Blanc

97.1

96

96

99

98-99

94-96+

98

L'If

96.8

96-98

96-98

96-97

Belair-Monange

96.8

95-97

97

96-98

96-97

96-98

96-98

Valandraud

96.6

95-97

97

96-98

95-97

97-98

95-97

96-98

Lynch Bages

96.6

96-98

97

96-97

95-97

Evangile

96.5

99

96-98

96-98

97-98

91-93

Smith Haut Lafitte

96.5

94-96

97

95-97+

96-98

96-97

96-98+

96-98

Troplong Mondot

96.5

96-98

96

96-98

95-97

Beausejour Duffau Lagarosse

96.5

95-97

98

95-97

97-99

95-96

96-98

94-96

Leoville Poyferre

96.5

95-97

96

96-98

96-97

96-98

La Mondotte

96.5

94-96

97-99

97-98

97-99

93-95

Pape Clement

96.4

95-97

95

96-99

95-97

96-97

96-98+

96-98

Calon Segur

96.4

96-98

97

96-98

95-96

95-97+

95-97

La Violette

96.4

96-99

96-98

94-96

95-97

Clinet

96.3

93-95

95

96-98

97-98

97-99

Pavie Macquin

96.2

93-95

97

95-97

95-97

98-99

95-97

95-97

Smith Haut Lafitte Blanc

96.1

96

94-96

97

96-97

96-98+

94-96

Clos Fourtet

96.1

95-97

97

95-97

95-96

95-97

La Fleur Petrus

96.1

97

96-98

96-97

94-96

94-96

Tertre Roteboeuf

96

94-96

95-97

96-98

95-97

Larcis Ducasse

95.9

94-96

94

95-97

95-97

98-99

95-97+

95-97

Hosanna

95.9

96-98

94

95-96

95-97

96-98

Le Dome

95.8

94-96

96

95-97+

95-97

95-96

96-98+

94-96

Peby Faugeres

95.8

94-96

96-98

95-97

96-97

94-96

94-96

Malescot St Exupery

95.8

94-96

96-97

95-97

Pavie Decesse

95.6

96-98

95

95-97+

93-95

96-97

95-97

94-96

Domaine de Chevalier

95.6

95-97

95

95-97

96-97

94-96+

94-96

Grand Puy Lacoste

95.6

96

95-97

94-95

95-97

Enclos Tourmaline

95.5

94

95-98

96-98

96-97

93-95+

94-96

Le Gay

95.5

94

96-99

95-97

96-97

93-95+

94-96

La Gaffeliere

95.5

94-96

95

95-96

95-97

95-97

Coutet

95.5

97

94-95

94-96

Chapelle de Labrie

95.5

95-96

Rocheyron

95.4

97

93-95

96-98

97-98

92-94+

93-95

Quintus

95.4

95

96-97

94-96+

94-96

Leoville Barton

95.4

94-96

96

95-96

94-96

Feytit Clinet

95.3

95

95-97+

95-97

95-96

93-95+

94-96

Bellevue Mondotte

95.3

93-95

95-97+

95-97

94-95

94-96

95-97

Guiraud

95.3

96

94-95

d'Issan

95.1

96

93-95+

94-96

96-97

94-96+

93-95

Tour St Christophe

95.1

95-97

94-96

96-97

92-94+

94-96

Canon La Gaffeliere

95.1

93-95

95

95-97

95-96

95-97+

93-95

Trottevieille

95.1

94-96

95

94-96

96-97

93-95

Suduiraut

95.1

94-96

96

92-94

95-96

94-96

95-97

Giscours

95.1

94-96

94

93-95

95-97

96-97

94-96

Pontet Labrie

95

94-96+

Magrez Fombrauge

95

96-99

92-93

Croix de Labrie

94.9

93

95-97

95-97

97-98

93-95+

92-94

Doisy Daene

94.9

93-95

96

94-95

94-96+

94-96

Brane Cantenac

94.9

96

93-95+

95-97

93-94

94-96

Domaine de Chevalier Blanc

94.9

93

97

95-96

94-96+

93-95

Lafaurie Peyraguey

94.9

98

93-95

94-95

92-94+

St Pierre (St Julien)

94.9

95

94-95

94-96+

94-96

Les Asteries

94.9

95-97+

94-95

94-96

93-95

Cos d'Estournel Blanc

94.9

97

94-96

95

97-98

92-94

91-93

Pape Clement Blanc

94.9

94

94-96

96

96-97

95-97

91-93

Clos L'Eglise (Pomerol)

94.9

92-94

95-97

96-97

93-95

94-96

Malartic Lagraviere

94.9

95

94-96

95-96

93-95

94-96

Batailley

94.9

94

94-96

95-96

94-96

Le Carre

94.8

94-96

94-96

94-95

Gazin

94.8

93

95-96

95-97

La Serre

94.8

94-96

94-95

Nenin

94.7

94

92-94

95-96

97-99+

92-94

Branaire Ducru

94.7

94-96

93

94-96

95-96

94-96

La Fleur Morange

94.7

95

94-96

93-95

Bellevue (Saint Emilion)

94.5

95

94-96

93-95+

93-95

Le Bon Pasteur

94.5

93-95

94-96

95-96

92-94+

94-96

Rouget

94.5

93-95

94

95-96

Aile d'Argent

94.5

95

95

97-98

93-95

90-92

Raymond Lafon

94.5

95

93-95

Langoa Barton

94.5

94

95-96

93-95

Rayne Vigneau

94.5

93

95-97

Soutard Cadet

94.3

94-96+

93-95

93-95

Vieux Chateau Mazerat

94.3

95

96-98

93-95

94-95

92-94

91-93

Laroque

94.3

92-94

93-95+

94-96

94-95

95-97

92-94

Clos St Martin

94.3

93-95

94-96

94-96

93-94

93-95

Valandraud Blanc

94.3

94

95-97

94-95

93-95

92-94

La Dominique

94.3

94-96

95-97

94-96

94-95

90-92

93-95

L'Enclos

94.3

94

94-95

Faugeres

94.3

93

95-96

Destieux

94.3

93-95

94-95

Sansonnet

94.2

93-95

93

93-95

94-96

94-95

94-96+

93-95

Barde Haut

94.2

93-95

95-96

92-94

Malartic Lagraviere Blanc

94.1

94

95

96-97

92-94+

91-93

Domaine de l'Eglise

94.1

93

96-98

96-97

89-91

Phelan Segur

94.1

93-95

94

93-95+

93-95

95-96

92-94

93-95

Beychevelle

94.1

92-94

94

95-97

93-94

93-95

Bellefont Belcier

94.1

92-94

94

95-97

94-96

95-96

90-92

93-95

Le Petit Mouton

94.1

92-94

94

93-95

93-95

96-97

92-94

93-95

Fonplegade

94

94-96

94

93-95

93-95

93-95

92-94

Doisy Vedrines

94

92-94

96

92-94

De Fargues

94

89-91

97

94-96

Clos De Sarpe

93.9

92-94

95-97

93-95

95-96

93-95+

92-94

Poesia

93.9

93-95

93-95

95-96

92-94+

92-94

Pavillon Rouge du Ch Margaux

93.9

94

93-95

96-97

92-94+

91-93

Lagrange St Julien

93.9

92-94

95

92-94

93-94

94-96

Cantenac Brown

93.9

92-94

94

93-95

93-94

94-96

Marquis d'Alesme Becker

93.9

94

93-95

93-94

92-94

94-96

Fleur Cardinale

93.9

93-95

92-94

95-96

93-95

92-94

Clos du Marquis

93.9

92-94

94-95

93-95

93-95

La Lagune

93.8

94

94-95

92-94

Siran

93.8

93

94-95

93-95

Talbot

93.8

93

94-95

93-95

Haut Batailley

93.8

92

95-96

93-95

Clos Dubreuil

93.8

93-95

94-95

92-94

Villemaurine

93.8

93-94

93-95

93-95

Clerc Milon

93.8

95

93-95

93-95

94-95

92-94+

91-93

Carruades de Lafite

93.8

92-94

93

94-96

93-95

95-96

91-93

Duhart Milon Rothschild

93.8

91-93

94

93-95

95-96

92-94

93-95

La Fleur De Gay

93.8

94

93-94

Le Pape

93.8

94

93-94

Le Clos du Beau Pere

93.8

93-95

93-94

Maillet

93.8

93-95

93-94

La Croix du Casse

93.8

92-94

94-95

Lynsolence

93.8

94-95

92-94

La Pointe

93.8

93-94

93-95

Lafon Rochet

93.7

93-95

93

93-95

93-94

93-95

Gloria

93.7

94

93-95

94-95

91-93

93-95

Guillot Clauzel

93.6

91-93

92

97-98

92-94+

Certan De May

93.6

94

94-96

94-95

90-92+

Gracia

93.6

92-94

94-96

92-94

92-93

94-96

92-94

Pedesclaux

93.6

94

93-95

92-94

94-95

93-95

91-93

Dauzac

93.5

93-95

94-95

91-93+

Le Petit Lion De Lascases

93.5

91-93

95-96

92-94+

Latour a Pomerol

93.5

92-94

94

93-95

93-94

92-94

Clos du Clocher

93.5

92-94

93

93-94

93-95

93-95

Sociando Mallet

93.5

94

93-94

92-94

Haut Marbuzet

93.5

93

94-95

92-94

La Tour Blanche

93.5

93

93-95

Poujeaux

93.5

92-94

93-95

La Croix de Beaucaillou

93.4

94

93-95

92-94

90-92

94-96

Lynch Moussas

93.4

92-94

92-94

94-95

92-94

Pagodes de Cos

93.4

93

94-95

92-94

92-94

De Pez

93.3

93-94

92-94+

Clos De L'Oratoire

93.3

92-94

92-94

94-95

92-94

92-94

La Clarence De Haut Brion

93.3

92-94

93

92-94

95-96

92-94

91-93

Bouscaut

93.3

93

93-94

Laroze

93.3

93-95

92-93

Le Boscq

93.3

91-93

94-95

Lafleur Gazin

93.3

94-95

91-93

Les Tourelles De Longueville

93.3

94-95

91-93

De Fieuzal

93.3

94-95

91-93

Cadet Bon

93.3

93-94

92-94

Branas Grand Poujeaux

93.3

93-94

92-94

Carbonnieux

93.3

93-94

92-94

Couvent des Jacobins

93.3

93-94

92-94

La Cabanne

93.3

93-94

92-94

La Fleur de Bouard

93.3

93-94

92-94

Mazeyres

93.3

93-94

92-94

Petit Gravet Aine

93.3

92-93

93-95

Larrivet Haut Brion Blanc

93.2

92

94-95

92-94

Fombrauge

93.2

93-95

92-93

92-94

Dalem

93.2

92-93

92-94

93-95

Clos Haut Peyraguey

93.1

93-95

93-95+

92-93

91-93+

92-94

Du Tertre

93.1

92-94

92

92-94+

91-93

95-96

Lascombes

93.1

92-94

94

91-93

94-95

93-95+

90-92

Grand Corbin Despagne

93.1

92-94

93

93-95

93-94

92-94+

91-93

Carillon de l'Angelus

93.1

93

94-95

91-93

92-94

Olivier Blanc

93

94

91-93+

La Tour Figeac

93

92-94

91-93+

93-95

Vray Croix De Gay

93

92-94

92-94+

92-94

La Marzelle

93

92-94

93-95

92-94

91-93+

92-94

Prieure Lichine

93

93-95

93

92-94

91-93

La Petite Eglise

93

92-94

93

92-94

92-94

La Chapelle De La Mission Haut Brion

93

93

92-94

Latour Martillac

92.9

92-94

92

93-94

92-94+

Montlandrie

92.9

93

91-93

92-93

93-95

92-94

Beauregard

92.9

94

92-93

92-94

91-93

Virginie De Valandraud

92.9

91

93-95

93-94

92-94

Grand Puy Ducasse

92.9

92-94

92-93

92-94

92-94

La Vieille Cure

92.8

94

92-93

91-93+

Franc Mayne

92.8

93-94

91-93+

Fontenil

92.8

92-93

92-94+

Capbern

92.8

92

92-94

93-94

Cantemerle

92.8

92-94

93-94

91-93

Le Prieure

92.8

94-96

95

90-93

91-93

91-93

90-92

Larrivet Haut Brion

92.8

92-94

93

92-94

91-93

D'Armailhac

92.8

93

92-94

91-93

92-94

Reserve De La Comtesse

92.8

93

91-93

92-94

92-94

Les Pagodes de Cos Blanc

92.8

95-96

89-91

Clos des Lunes Lune D'Argent

92.8

92-93

92-94

La Commanderie

92.8

92-93

92-94

La Dauphine

92.8

92-93

92-94

La Louviere

92.8

92-93

92-94

Les Trois Croix

92.8

92-93

92-94

Corbin

92.7

93

93

91-93

La Fleur D'Arthus

92.7

93

91-93

92-94

Lilian Ladouys

92.6

92-94

92-93

91-93+

92-94

Petit Village

92.6

92-94

92

96-97

88-90

Labegorce

92.6

92

92-94

91-92

93-95

Kirwan

92.5

93

90-92

93-94

Cantegril

92.5

91

91-94

93-95

Les Aromes De Pavie

92.5

90

93-95

94-95

92-94

90-92

Les Griffons de Pichon Baron

92.5

92-94

91-93

Chauvin

92.5

90-92

93-95

Grand Mayne

92.5

89-91

92

91-92

94-96

Bourgneuf

92.4

93

93-94

89-91+

92-94

Calicem

92.4

90-92

95-96

91-93

90-92

Dassault

92.4

94

90-92

91-94

91-93

Marquis de Terme

92.3

93

93-95

92-93

90-92+

90-92

Les Cruzelles

92.3

92-94

93

90-92

Latour Martillac Blanc

92.3

92

91-93

92-94

Fonroque

92.3

93-95

91-93

90-92

Marquis de Calon

92.3

92-94

93

92-93

90-92

91-93

La Clarte De Haut Brion Blanc

92.3

92

93

93-94

90-92

92

Moulin Du Cadet

92.3

92-94

90

94-96

90-92

Monbousquet

92.3

93-95

92-94

90-92

90-92

Chapelle De La Mission Haut Brion

92.3

94-95

89-91

La Fleur (St Emilion)

92.3

93-94

90-92

Bonalgue

92.3

92-93

91-93

l'Eveche

92.3

92-93

91-93

Potensac

92.2

90-92

94-95

90-92+

Fonbadet

92.2

92-93

90-92+

92-94

Meyney

92.1

93

92-93

90-92+

91-93

Cote De Baleau

92

89-91+

93-95

Le Petit Haut Lafitte

92

92-94

92

91-93

90-92

91-93

Clos Floridene Blanc

92

93

90-92

Clos Rene

91.9

89-91

91-94

90-92

93-95

Bolaire

91.8

92-93

90-92+

91-93

Frank Phelan

91.8

91

92-93

Croizet Bages

91.8

93-94

89-91

Le Dragon de Quintus

91.8

93-94

89-91

Saintayme

91.7

94

89-91

90-92

Le Petit Haut Lafitte Blanc

91.7

92

91-93

90-92

Fourcas Dupre

91.5

91-93

90-92

Charmail

91.5

90-92

91-93

Clos St Julien

91.4

93-95

90-94

93-95

85-87

Domaine de la Solitude

91.3

94-96

91

89-90

88-90

Goulee

91.2

92

92-93

88-90

Clos Floridene

91

90-92

Clos Manou

91

90-92

Haut Sarpe

90.8

89-91

88

90-93

89-91

93-95

90-92

Couhins-Lurton

90.8

89-90

93

89-91

89-91

Senejac

90.5

90-92

89-91

Pibran

16.5

90-92

91-92

90-92

Lafleur

99

Latour

99

Canon

98

Cheval Blanc

98

Montrose

98

Palmer

98

Petrus

98

Beausejour Becot

96

Les Carmes Haut Brion

96

Pavillon Blanc du Ch Margaux

96

Rauzan Segla

96

Sigalas Rabaud

95

Beausite

94-95

Boutisse

94-95

Cap De Mourlin

94-95

Chatelet

94-95

Ferrand

94-95

Laforge

94-95

Lassegue

94-95

Les Hauts de Croix de Labrie

94-95

Pauillac (Domaine Peyronie)

94-95

S de Suduiraut

94-95

Saint Georges Cote Pavie

94-95

Vieux Maillet

94-95

Mangot Todeschini

93-95+

Alter Ego de Palmer

94

Dame de Montrose

94

Ferriere

94

Le Thil (Comte Clary)

94

Virginie de Valandraud Blanc

94

Lafaurie Peyraguey Blanc Sec

93-95

La Croix St Georges

93-95

Faurie de Souchard

93-95

Les Grandes Murailles

93-95

L'Hermitage Lescours

93-95

Rol Valentin

93-95

Badette

93-94

Balestard La Tonnelle

93-94

Bel Air (Pomerol)

93-94

Blason d'Issan

93-94

Brown

93-94

Cantin

93-94

Cap Leon Veyrin

93-94

Carbonnieux Blanc

93-94

Carignan

93-94

Clos Badon - Thunevin

93-94

Clos des Lunes Lune d'Or

93-94

Condat

93-94

Couhins Rouge

93-94

Couhins-Lurton Blanc

93-94

Daugay

93-94

de Carles

93-94

Fayat

93-94

Haut Brisson

93-94

Haut Carles

93-94

Haut Veyrac

93-94

Jean Faure

93-94

La Grave A Pomerol

93-94

La Louviere Blanc

93-94

La Patache

93-94

La Reverence

93-94

La Tour Carnet

93-94

Lafon La Tuilerie

93-94

Lamarque

93-94

Larmande

93-94

Le Merle de Peby Faugeres

93-94

Le Rey

93-94

Lespault Martillac

93-94

Marojallia

93-94

Marsau

93-94

Martinet

93-94

Mondou

93-94

Montlisse

93-94

Moulin Haut Laroque

93-94

Pierhem

93-94

Reserve de Malartic Lagraviere

93-94

Reserve de Malartic Lagraviere Blanc

93-94

Tour des Termes

93-94

Rolland Maillet

92-94

Clos Junet

92-94+

Mangot

92-94+

Belle Vue (Haut Medoc)

93

Berliquet

93

Clos Puy Arnaud

93

Haut Bages Liberal

93

La Chapelle De La Mission

93

La Croix de Gay

93

Les Forts De Latour

93

Pensees de Lafleur

93

Petit Cheval

93

Segla

93

Tronquoy Lalande

93

La Confession

92-94

Clos Lunelles

92-94

La Prade

92-94

Olivier

92-94

Camensac

92-94

Chasse Spleen

92-94

Clos Cantenac

92-94

Grand Corbin Manuel

92-94

Grand Ormeau

92-94

La Creation

92-94

La Voute

92-94

Les Ormes De Pez

92-94

Pouget

92-94

Roc De Cambes

92-94

3 de Valandraud

92-93

Adaugusta

92-93

Baron de Brane

92-93

Bastor Lamontagne

92-93

Bel Air Cuvee Jean Gabriel

92-93

Bel Air Ouy

92-93

Bellegrave (Pomerol)

92-93

Bibian

92-93

Calice de Faugeres

92-93

Camille de Labrie Chardonnay

92-93

Cap de Faugeres

92-93

Chantegrive Cuvee Caroline

92-93

Chardonnay

92-93

Clarke

92-93

Clos Beauregard

92-93

Clos des Jacobins

92-93

Clos Margalaine

92-93

Couhins Blanc

92-93

Croix Cardinale

92-93

Croix de Labrie Stella Solare Blanc

92-93

de France

92-93

de la Huste

92-93

des Laurets

92-93

du Cartillon

92-93

du Gaby

92-93

du Glana

92-93

du Paradis

92-93

Ducluzeau

92-93

Fourcas Hosten

92-93

Haut Chaigneau

92-93

Haut Madrac

92-93

La Fleur de Rocheyron

92-93

La Garde

92-93

La Garde Blanc

92-93

La Rousselle

92-93

La Sergue

92-93

La Tour de Mons

92-93

La Vieille Dame de Trottevieille

92-93

Labastide Dauzac

92-93

Labat

92-93

Lalande (St. Julien)

92-93

Laniotte

92-93

l'Archange

92-93

Larose Perganson

92-93

Larrivaux

92-93

Le Haut Medoc de Dauzac

92-93

Le Menuet des Jacobins

92-93

Lecuyer

92-93

Les Haut Medoc de Lascombes

92-93

Lestage simon

92-93

L'Etoile d eBon Pasteur

92-93

L'Infini de Chateau de Francs

92-93

Lions de Batailley

92-93

Lucia

92-93

Malmaison

92-93

Mongravey

92-93

Monregard la Croix

92-93

Montlabert

92-93

Moulin a Vent (Moulis)

92-93

Picque Caillou

92-93

Pierre 1er

92-93

Pierre de Lune

92-93

Ramafort

92-93

Relais de la Dominique

92-93

St Andre Corbin

92-93

St Pierre (Pomerol)

92-93

Tour Maillet

92-93

Trimoulet

92-93

Quintus Le Dragon De Quintus

91-93

Beaumont

91-93

Brisson

91-93

Les Hauts De Smith Blanc

91-93

Reignac

91-93

Reynon

91-93

La Gurgue

90

Pauillac De Ch Latour

90

Lacoste Borie

89-91

La Chenade

88-90

No 3 d'Angelus

88-90

Pastourelle De Clerc Milon

88-90

Subscribe to our emails
Get the best of F+R delivered to your inbox
We use cookies to give you the best possible experience of our website. If you continue, we’ll assume you’re happy for your web browser to receive all cookies from our website. See our cookie policy for more information on cookies and how to manage them.